The Final Review-Team Obey
The main complaint seems to be customer service, although quality relative to price would be a close second. Overall, this nail salon has a terrible online buzz with comments ranging from the place was unfriendly to the place was scary.
For the most part, these people seemed to be split by gender on their motivation to write the reviews. The two women are both regular contributors to Yelp, one has 65 reviews and the other has 238. This shows that they probably didn’t write the review simply because they were angry, but because doing this sort of thing is part of their regular routine. The men on the other hand have written 12 reviews and 15 reviews. Doug, the user that has written 15 reviews, was the only positive reviewer and the review was short with no specifics. It almost seems like he has an affiliation with Hollywood Nails and Spa and just went on Yelp to provide a good review. The other man that wrote a review is not a regular user on Yelp and most likely wrote the review because his experience was so negative.
The apparent motivations seem to be to inform others and to warn them before other consumers stubble into this particular nail salon. One reviewer simply states that Hollywood Nails and Spa isn’t worth the money, but two others go much further and actively try to dissuade people from going. As far as hidden motivations, I think that Walt was blowing off steam a little bit with his negative review and Doug may have gotten lucky with his experience but as he was the only positive review in a sea of scathing reviews, it seems a little suspicious.
Most of the reviews for Hollywood Nails and Spa were very negative and could be a potential problem of in finding new customers. Seeing as we are smart marketers now would be the time to engage our customers and develop a more personal relationship. Who are we or what have we become would be the first question asked in developing a new movement for Hollywood. Like Brian Solis said “give it a person, personality, voice, and presence”. Right now this company has a presence and a personality which people are not satisfied with. How do we change that, well good thing we are the owners and we can take action at our salon.
From what we learned by listening to our previous customers is that the salon is a bit frightening and it seems that the customers are seen as dollars. Being a salon tends to demand a more personal approach to each customer and make them feel more like your friend instead of client. In order to change this it must begin with management. They have to take the first step in making the clients feel like part of the Hollywood Nail and Spa family. If the current management can not accomplish this then new management must be hired. Now that the atmosphere has changed it time to engage the customers.
Word of mouth would be the strongest tool that is used if a better experience was encounter by the customers. Employees would also be another great tool to engage customers online. Employees should take the time to get personal with the customers in which a friendship could be developed as opposed to being another manicurist. Making that connection could potentially lead to engagement online such as Facebook or Twitter. Once that connection is established Hollywood Nails is making its presence online through employees. Facebook would be used to promote the company and also develop a sense of belonging with the customer. With the permission of the customers we would post pictures of them on our page as to market our products and services. By doing this you would make the customer feel like a part of something, and by involving them it will encourage the customer interact more.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/hollywood-nails-and-spa-dallas
Solis, Brian. Engage!: the Complete Guide for Brands and Businesses to Build, Cultivate, and Measure Success in the New Web. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2011.
Frances/Reviews
We decided to look at the reviews from the elites’ of Yelp to get more trusted and in depth opinions on Frances, a newer restaurant to the San Francisco area. Yelp’s elite squad is comprised of “Yelpers” with a high quantity of quality reviews that applied and were selected by Yelp. The reviews for Frances are generally good with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5. We decided to look at a 2, 3, 4, and a 5-star review from the elites’ and wanted to critique a 1 star review, but no elites’ reviewed it as such.
These reviewers, being elites’, are people who are passionate about getting their opinions, suggestions, and complaints read by as many people as possible. Judging by each of their pages, they all thoroughly enjoy food and have reviewed several restaurants. Most of the reviewers are from San Francisco (where Frances is located), but there are also many reviews from people around the world.
Common complaints that showed up in most of the reviews stated that there was a lack of space, long wait time, overcrowding, and below par house wine. The 2-star review by Jean K. said that the small restaurant had lost its neighborhood feel because it was “packed”. One reviewer, Helen T., claimed that there was a 3 month waiting period for reservations for dining room seating and she had to wait for an hour and 10 minutes to get a seat at the bar.
One of the reviewers, Nancy L., put on her profile “I yelp because I care”. This statement shows the passion of the selected reviewers. To reiterate our previous point from the second paragraph, these reviewers want their opinions heard so they can help people make more informed decisions about whether or not to go to this restaurant. A hidden reason a person may post a review about a restaurant is if they had a bad experience at the restaurant, they may want to keep as many people from going to that place as possible.
A marketer that wanted to take advantage of these reviews could gather that the restaurants customer base/ demand for seating is too large for the location. This presents an opportunity and a complication. Frances has the opportunity to expand to a larger location but risks losing more of the neighborhood feel and losing some of the local regular customers if they change locations. With the large amount of highly rated reviews by customers, it seems that Frances is meeting most of the wants and needs of their customers.
http://www.yelp.com/elite
Week 13-15
2) Pick the top 4-5 reviews, read them. Also, if you click on the reviewers' names, you will be led to their personal profile pages.
3) Now, read the reviews, take note of the profile pages, and reflect on the following questions:
a) who are these people? Where do they belong (go beyond their city of residence; we know that already)? These people are from their local areas of where the business is located.
b) What is their main complaint(s)? Complaining about how expensive the nails salon is and how it doesn’t take longer than 20 minutes to wax someone’s eyebrows or even get a pedicure for 30- 40 minutes.
c) What do you think motivated them write such an extensive review? (especially considering the fact that you and me typically don't do the same even when we are thoroughly satisfied or dissatisfied with the products that we consume. These people wrote such a big review because their mad and angry like I would be if I were them. I don’t want to sit and wait all day to get something done that should only take the minimum. I know businesses get busy at times, but lots of nail places have about 40 people working at the same time.
d) What are the most apparent and some hidden motivations? These people are complaining for the safety and time consuming of others. Obviously this nail salon isn’t very careful of what they are “good” at.
4) If you are a smart marketer (which you are!) (lets say the owners of the businesses listed on the respective pages), how do you deal with this information? What are your courses of action? More importantly, how do you engage with these potential 'influencers' so that you develop a steady stream of a positive feedback/WOM loop that will stay online and attract other consumers? If this was my business, and I had customers complaining about what’s going on in my business, I would call or contact these people and ask them how to better my business, or even read what their complaining about and start with that and fix that so that the customers see improvement. I would also ask them to reconsider coming back to the business and giving them a more relaxing time then the previous.
New and Old P’s
week 1 blog post
Social Media 4P's
"THE OTHERS"
Week 1: Sept. 6-8
In a networked world it is all about the connection, so I have to say that the internet the reason why being connected is easier. Many people are needy for information, the faster and easier they can get it the happier they are. Which is why managers have changed their techniques for planning the four P’s to adapt to their consumers. When a product or service is being presented by a business it typical way may be through the internet. These tasks could go through email, facebook, twitter, and etc. If a consumer show interest in a product the company is then able to go forth and keep their consumer aware of any new product through these sources consumer may give to them. A marketer can plan the whole process of product development through the internet.
One implication of how the networked world has affected the planning could be the act of introducing a product of the basis of feedback. A general example would be an existing product that has received quite a few feedbacks, some may be applauding and others may express what they wish they could add to your product. In this case, you may build off the feedback received and venture off from that or improve for the future. Feedback has changed because a high percentage of people have access to the internet, therefore, there is more feedback for these companies to see, and whether it is good or bad there is more of it for people to set their own judgment. Typically, when a customer would like to purchase a product, a little research goes into the process, in which, a customer has the ability to view the feedback. This tool makes it easier and faster for consumers to research efficiently before they consider buying.
One example the changes of product development has on a company is TOMS. Over the last five years that this company has been in business they have been able to promote not only a great product but an even better message. TOMS shoes were not offered in stores in the beginning because of the lack of staff they had to make the shoes, so this company started off as online based only. The first products introduced by TOMS were shoes, their motto was, “One for One.” What they mean by this is, for every pair of shoes purchased, a child in need would also receive a pair of shoes. From being entirely based on the internet, to know selling in numerous department stores, and also online, TOMS has made themselves quite a name.
Refrences
http://amarillo.com/news/local-news/2011-04-06/students-bare-their-soles
http://www.toms.com/blog
Industry Change (PNB)
Corporate airplanes have been used by individuals, corporations, presidents, and families since the 1940's. Up into the 1990's the only way to find a plane was to either A. go to the factory and buy a plane off the assembly line(if the purchase was a brand new plane). Or B. go through an aircraft broker. This puts all 4 P's into one of two places. There are many different factors that go into the purchase of a new or used aircraft. When many people think of airplane purchases, they only think of buying the aircraft. The "networked world" or Internet has allowed people to gather information about any type of equipment as it relates to their purchase.
Although the aircraft market is a very niche line of sales, individuals are able to explore the vast market of aircraft for sale. Websites have been created that allow people to shop for aircraft by type without the broker(websites below).
The websites have also allowed sellers to sell without the use of aircraft sales companies. Although these companies still exist, business is not thriving as it did it in the past.
Other companies that have taken advantage of the aircraft selling/purchasing process include the equipment companies such as Garmin. Garmin equipment is found in cars, airplanes, helecopters, boats, and many others. They have used satellite technology that get their products into many different products across many markets. Garmin contracts with producers to get their equipment into the other industries' new product sales. Because of the highly recommended Garmin products, aircraft producers put Garmin' products into their aircraft consequently raising the price of the aircraft. The strategy helps promote both industries.
When it comes to the 4 P's. Product has not changes dramatically. Aircraft are still being bought and sold on a regular basis. Companies that put their equipment into aircraft are still using the same strategy to get their product into the aircraft. Price has been slightly effected. Because the information is there for all to see and available for everyone, the prices have slightly declined. The economy has greatly changed the price of aircraft; however, that is a discussion not related to marketing. Promotions have always been present in the market and will always be in the market. Individuals are able to watch the price of particular aircraft change by using the websites stated below. The negotiations always happen and asking price always may differ from selling price. Placement is the "P" that has changed most dramatically. It has created a situation that has led to the disappearance of many jobs in the aircraft sales industry. Aircraft brokers have become obsolete with the establishment of the Internet and expansion of aircraft marketing.
www.controller.com
www.aso.com
www.airplanetrader.com